This past week, I got into a discussion with a colleague about the differences between collaborative and dictatorial management styles. I have had managers who were at both ends of the spectrum and also some who were in the middle. I once worked for a CEO who’s favorite line was, “Everyone has the right to their own opinion, no matter how wrong it might be. Now go do what I asked you to do.” While it made everyone laugh, he clearly wasn’t interested in anyone’s input. He simply wanted to direct and have blind followers. There are certainly case studies where this has worked well. However, brilliant managers who have all the answers are few and far between. Additionally, building a company of “lemmings” who are not allowed to have vision or any form of opinion isn’t the recipe for a successful business.
I have always been a manager who has worked hard to create collaboration and alignment. I’ve found that allowing teams to gel and share opinions has always worked well. I like to build a staff of smart people who are experts in their specialty and then facilitate success.
This philosophy is even more important today when we have virtual teams. It is rare that members of teams work in the same office or even in the same state. In many cases they live in various countries. The rich diversity of skills, education, experience and culture bring different perspectives to the team. Everyone brings a unique set of ideas. The combination of thoughts can create new ideas that bring tremendous competitive advantage.
The management skill that needs to be developed is the ability to “orchestrate” the noise to create music rather than conflict and chaos. Many managers feel threatened by teams who offer new ideas or constructive feedback. It is important to remember that the rich resource within the team is what creates the strongest solutions. One must be willing to accept input from the team and then coordinate that input into a unified solution.
While not an actual business case study, I would like to share a video that illustrates the concept of collaborating diversity extremely well. As a Rolling Stones fan, Gimme Shelter is one of my favorite songs. I would never have thought that the collaboration of artists from around the world would have “crowdsourced” a version of the song that rivals the original. However, this video brilliantly demonstrates the value of unique approaches to the same problem and the resulting solution being as good, or possibly better than a true classic. Enjoy…
If you enjoyed this post, please subscribe to the email or RSS feed.
Most companies are continually managing the lifecycles of their key products. Marketing teams are researching industry trends, looking for new opportunities. Engineering departments are developing new products to satisfy market requirements. Product teams are sustaining existing products by introducing incremental enhancements. Finally, older products are being removed from the market to make room for newer models. The cycle never ends.
I have been lucky enough to know, and work with, a lot of “successful” business people in my career. I was able to meet and work with the founders of Network Appliance (NetApp) when they were just a small startup in San Jose, CA. I worked for a company who had Ray Noorda (the founder of Novell) as the chairman of the board and was able to interface with him many times. I worked with many dot-com startups who made millions “overnight”. I also worked with many other successful business people who never had home runs, but were able to string together a series of singles, doubles and triples and do just as well as the dot-com overnight successes.
I noticed something very interesting this Christmas holiday. Many of my neighbors were putting up their own Christmas lights. This was a big change for our street. When we first moved into the neighborhood over ten years ago, everyone put up their own lights. But fairly quickly advertisements arrived offering inexpensive services to install and remove the Christmas lights. No one enjoyed getting up on the roof, and the economy was good, so most families started using local vendors to put them up. However, this year more people were out decorating as a family. It is something I am noticing a lot more of lately. Less people are using vendors and tradesmen, and more people are learning to do things themselves.
Sizzle vs. Substance – it is a classic marketing debate. When putting together a marketing campaign, what is the right balance of sizzle vs. substance? This issue also translates into press releases, trade show strategies, advertising, internal business presentations, speeches, resumes and almost any form of communication. The obvious answer is that it depends on the message itself and the vehicle used to communicate the message.
I opened my eyes this morning wide enough to see 5:45am on the alarm clock. It was warm in my bed and it was cold outside. People shouldn’t get up at 5:45am on a Saturday morning. I could think of a thousand reasons to stay in bed and I could only think of one to get out of bed – to get on the road and ride my bike. However, it was still dark outside, and it was very comfortable next to my wife under the covers.
It has been raining all weekend. This morning while I was working in the home office, my 11-year-old son came in, slouched in the leather chair, stared at me and gave me his best “I’m bored speech”. Apparently, there was nothing on television, his brother was on the computer, and his complete library of video games was “mega-boring”. After 5 minutes of negotiation, I finally caved in and agreed to put the bills aside and spend some father/son bonding time with him. I decided to go “old school” and pull out the slot-car set that he received several years ago for Christmas.
How many products (or services) do you purchase that truly delight you the way toys did when you were an 11-year old? Your answer is probably, “very few”. You can make the argument that nothing gets you excited the way things did when you were 11 years old. However, I can probably point you to a dozen or so purchases that still do. Have you ever purchased a car that just amazed you at how wonderful the experience was? Did you ever take a cruise or stay at a hotel that you couldn’t stop talking about? There are the obvious examples of outstanding service (e.g., Nordstrom) and consumer electronics (e.g., Apple). However I can think of several little known companies and products that truly made me feel like they should have charged more for the experience.
One of my favorite business books was published in 1988. It was a very simple book entitled, “


